Close Menu
Invest Insider News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Thursday, November 19
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
    Invest Insider News
    • Home
    • Bitcoin
    • Commodities
    • Finance
    • Investing
    • Property
    • Stock Market
    • Utilities
    Invest Insider News
    Home»Utilities»Utility Affordability: Who Pays for the Grid’s Next Chapter? | Spilman Thomas & Battle, PLLC
    Utilities

    Utility Affordability: Who Pays for the Grid’s Next Chapter? | Spilman Thomas & Battle, PLLC

    November 19, 202610 Mins Read


    Luke Sternick, Spilman Thomas & Battle Law Clerk, contributed to this article.

    Utility rate affordability is the new paramount issue facing the nation, impacting consumers, energy providers, emerging technologies and industries, and the regulators tasked with keeping these interests balanced. For residential consumers, utility costs are just one component of the constantly rising cost of living. For commercial and industrial consumers, utility affordability shapes economics and internal decisions about where to expand (or whether they can remain in business). For energy providers and utilities, the question defines how much capital can be invested and recovered, and how quickly. For data center developers, the cost of energy increasingly determines whether, where, and when a project can connect.

    A recent Utility Dive commentary from Grid Forward executive director, Bryce Yonker, reports that average U.S. electric rates rose from 10.59 cents per kilowatt-hour in 2020 to 13.63 cents in 2025, representing an increase of roughly 29 percent over that five-year period, even as major reliability outages have simultaneously surged. The advocacy group PowerLines alternatively estimates that average utility bills have risen approximately 40 percent since 2021, further finding that utilities requested $31 billion in rate increases in 2025 alone. In 2026, the group has reported a record 3Q quarterly total of about $4.5 billion in new requests, bringing the 2026 year-to-date figure to an astounding $23.1 billion. Similarly, Shipley Energy reports that the U.S. Energy Information Administration expects the average residential price to climb from 17.3 cents per kilowatt-hour in 2025 to 18.2 cents in 2026.

    Regulators, for their part, are approving these increases – in some measure – more often than in the past. Citing Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL) data, PowerLines notes that over the past five years, commissions have approved on average 64 percent of the dollar value of requested increases, compared with 52 percent over the prior 20 years. Politically, the stakes are obvious. According to the data, 62 percent of Americans (the electorate) reported higher electric or natural gas bills over the past year, with 73 percent indicating worry over further increases.

    It is easy to target new data centers and large load requirements as the “elephant in the room” causing these higher costs; however, it is important to resist single-cause explanations. LBNL’s literature review on large loads, which summarizes its 2026 retail price trends update, describes a national picture with myriad regional and state-level drivers of the price spike. These drivers include multiple factors, including fuel costs, storm recovery costs, aging assets, inflation in the cost of labor and materials, and a surge in capital investment, along with unprecedented load growth.

    The most reliable leading indicator of future rate requests is record-level capital spending. PowerLines’ review of 51 investor-owned utility earnings calls found plans to spend at least $1.4 trillion through 2030. This is 21 percent above the prior year’s five-year total. S&P Global’s Regulatory Research Associates projects a record $1.295 trillion for the 46 energy companies it tracks for 2026–2030, with 2026 spending roughly 29 percent above the approximately $200 billion spent in 2025. S&P attributes the increase to grid modernization, reliability and resilience, and new generation and transmission needed to serve large loads.

    Critically, a significant portion of that spending is not about growth at all. An LBNL scoping study of distribution costs found that distribution costs account for roughly 32 percent of the national-average increase in retail rates since 2014. Among 22 utilities LBNL sampled, 15 identified maintaining the existing distribution system as their largest planned CAPEX category; capacity expansion led for only two. PowerLines’ analysis of third-quarter filings tells a similar story: transmission and distribution investment was at least partially behind $2.8 billion of the $3.6 billion in requests it examined.

    The current regulatory model magnifies these dynamics. Utilities earn an authorized return on capital investment. S&P Global estimates the average authorized utility returns on equity at about 9.84 percent, and PowerLines suggests that this structure favors building over optimizing. Utility Dive similarly identifies a regulatory solution that would align incentives with required outcomes, including the efficient use of capital, and further calls for an approach of standardizing utility equipment that could mitigate project complexity and cost for common functionality issues that individual utilities still largely custom order.

    No recent development has impacted the energy grid landscape more than the arrival of very large loads. LBNL has devoted significant research to this issue and now estimates that U.S. data center electricity demand grew 2.3 times between 2018 and 2024 and could grow 3.3 times from 2024 to 2028, and projects data centers at about 11.8 percent of total U.S. electricity usage by 2030. Utility Dive reports that interconnection requests that once totaled 30 to 100 megawatts per project are now approaching 1 gigawatt and more.

    The negative side. The clearest evidence of cost impact comes from PJM Interconnection, whose capacity auction price rose from $28.92 per megawatt-day for 2024/2025 to $329.17 for 2026/2027, according to the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. As reported by Utility Dive, PJM’s independent market monitor concluded in 2025 that data center load growth is the “primary reason” for recent and expected capacity market conditions. Across the last four auctions, the PJM Market Monitor attributes $29.4 billion in costs to data center demand, as reported by The Hill. The impact on residential consumers has been evident, with some customers in the Washington, D.C. area experiencing average increases of about $21 per month beginning June 2025, roughly half of which the D.C. consumer advocate attributes to capacity prices. A Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas study, summarized in LBNL’s review, estimates that existing data centers have already raised wholesale energy prices by 2 percent to 6 percent on average nationally, and by more than 10 percent in places such as northern Virginia.

    The potential burden of large loads impacts customer classes differently. According to one report, for residential households, capacity charges make up roughly 10 percent of a typical bill, while for industrial and manufacturing consumers the share can be up to three times higher. The same piece reports that industrial electricity prices had risen 31 percent in Pennsylvania and 26 percent in Ohio as of December 2025, against a 7 percent nationwide average. And the question of how those costs are allocated is jurisdictionally split. According to Cumulant, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s June 2026 show-cause orders target large-load integration and wholesale cost shifting, but leave retail class allocation to the states. Any complete solution must therefore pass through both a federal wholesale rule change and multiple state retail proceedings.

    The positive side. The picture is not one-directional. In a study summarized by LBNL, a new large load can lower rates for others when a system has capacity headroom. If existing generation and transmission can serve the load with little new investment, those large load payments may help recover fixed costs across a broader base. LBNL found that residential customers in some states may have benefited from load growth between 2019 and 2025, though it cautions that the relationship may change. PowerLines makes the same observation, noting that rising demand, if managed well, could spread fixed costs over more kilowatt-hours. That said, timing matters. As reported by LBNL, The Dallas Fed study found that Texas, despite its heavy data center concentration, saw minimal price impact because of aggressive supply buildout.

    Large-load tariffs. The dominant response across states is the introduction of so-called large-load tariffs. Utility Dive reported in March that, according to the Smart Electric Power Alliance (SEPA), 77 such tariffs were pending or in place across 36 states, and that state regulators approved 29 in 2025, versus 14 from 2018 through 2024. Early evidence suggests that these tariffs may screen out speculative requests. As reported by Utility Dive, AEP Ohio cut its large-load forecast by more than half, from 30 gigawatts to 13 gigawatts, after its tariff was approved, although manufacturers in the state contend that data center demand remains inflated. And this approach does not begin to address the critical question of who pays for infrastructure development and upgrades and how those costs are allocated.

    State-specific, consumer protection models. States are also beginning to take a concerted stand in favor of protecting consumers against the potential rising cost implications of new large loads. For example, Oregon’s Public Utility Commission approved a framework for Portland General Electric that creates a dedicated rate class for large loads that, among other things, requires those large loads to fund 100 percent of distribution network upgrades, sets minimum generation and transmission demand charges at 90 percent of contracted capacity, and ties contract terms of 10 to 30 years to project size. Similarly, Pennsylvania regulators, for example, have proposed a model tariff with a 50-megawatt threshold (100 megawatts aggregated), a five-year minimum term, an 80 percent minimum billing demand, financial security for network upgrades, lower charges for customers with onsite generation or interruptible service, and annual contributions to utility hardship funds. New York has opened a proceeding to revisit interconnection, cost allocation and tariff structures for large loads. In Texas, Gov. Greg Abbott in August 2026 directed regulators and ERCOT to audit every data center seeking a grid connection, citing requests exceeding 474 gigawatts. Several states, including Oregon, Minnesota, Indiana, Texas, and Virginia, also have enacted laws governing how large-load customers are treated.

    Even at the wholesale level, PJM’s market monitor has recommended that data centers bring their own generation or be served through a dedicated auction, so that other customers do not bear their capacity costs. Meanwhile, price caps negotiated after pressure from governors, led by Pennsylvania’s, now extend through 2029.

    Beyond data centers. As noted above, however, large load rules address only part of the problem. In addition to solutions already discussed, the Utility Dive commentary lists additional considerations to potentially address the mounting affordability crisis. These considerations – some well-known and some novel – include (1) removing the federal tariffs that increase the cost of materials used to support the grid; (2) scaling the available cost-effective measures that already put downward pressure on rates, such as energy efficiency, demand-side management, and grid flexibility; and (3) exploring emerging solutions that use and optimize the grid infrastructure that is currently in place, particularly during “non-peak” periods, rather than investing in brand new (and costly) transmission upgrades. Other creative solutions may also exist, including maintaining the competitive advantage of diverse ownership of grid-scale battery support.

    Utility affordability will not be resolved by any single reform. The drivers, from aging assets to load growth to the incentives built into cost-of-service regulation, are structural. Still, several practical themes emerge. Industrial customers should monitor large-load tariff dockets closely to ensure that definitions and cost allocation do not unintentionally reach them. Energy providers should expect heightened scrutiny of capital plans and load forecasts, and a growing expectation for demonstrated prudence. Data center developers must anticipate longer commitments, collateral, and exit obligations as the price of speed to power, and should consider flexibility and self-supply as differentiators. State commissions, particularly in vertically integrated states, should identify and protect captive ratepayers from paying for unnecessary investment by utilities and investment that is being made principally to meet the needs of new large loads. All stakeholders should expect affordability to remain a central issue in rate cases, legislative sessions, and elections for the foreseeable future.



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleBitcoin Deflation Warning vs. Debasement Hedge: McGlone vs. Seyffart

    Related Posts

    Utilities

    State Utilities Commissioner resigns days after Duke rate case and carbon plan ruling

    November 19, 2026
    Utilities

    Ecofin Utilities (LSE:EGL) Updates Investors Below FTSE 100

    November 19, 2026
    Utilities

    How a deadly California utility company ‘bought’ Gavin Newsom

    November 19, 2026
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    How is the UK Commercial Property Market Performing?

    December 31, 2000

    How much are they in different states across the US?

    December 31, 2000

    A Guide To Becoming A Property Developer

    December 31, 2000
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • WhatsApp
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Latest Reviews
    Stock Market

    Share Talk Weekly Stock Market News Review, Sunday 28th July 2024 – Share Talk

    July 28, 2024
    Stock Market

    Stock Market Today: U.S. Stocks Edge Higher as SpaceX Steals the Spotlight

    June 12, 2026
    Bitcoin

    Bitcoin (BTC) Price: Whales Dumped 66% of Holdings at $74K Peak — Data Analysis

    March 8, 2026
    What's Hot

    Bitcoin and CBDC, Russia Wants Both

    July 19, 2024

    Extreme heat drives up utility costs as Rocky Mountain Power requests rate increases

    August 14, 2024

    Bitcoin Price Forecast: Macro Shifts and BoJ Policy Signal Bullish Bias

    December 27, 2025
    Most Popular

    Le gouverneur de l’Arizona qualifie les Crypto d’« investissement non testé » et s’oppose au projet de loi sur la réserve de Bitcoin

    May 3, 2025

    8 Charts Showing Why the Market Is Bullish, Bearish, and Everything In Between

    September 29, 2025

    Bitcoin Could Deliver 25x ROI by 2026 as VET and WLD Gain Analyst Backing

    September 7, 2025
    Editor's Picks

    LE POINT CRYPTOS : Le bitcoin flirte avec son record, Forge lance un stablecoin en dollar

    June 10, 2025

    Anthropic signs $35 billion cloud deal with Nvidia-backed Lambda, WSJ reports By Investing.com

    August 31, 2026

    United Utilities anticipated to close road in Clitheroe

    January 9, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
    • Get In Touch
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    © 2026 Invest Insider News

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.