Close Menu
Invest Insider News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Tuesday, November 17
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
    Invest Insider News
    • Home
    • Bitcoin
    • Commodities
    • Finance
    • Investing
    • Property
    • Stock Market
    • Utilities
    Invest Insider News
    Home»Utilities»Utilities are public services – and should not be run as businesses | Utilities
    Utilities

    Utilities are public services – and should not be run as businesses | Utilities

    October 2, 20263 Mins Read


    Will Hutton and Andy Haldane advocate “turning [utilities] into public-benefit companies with a primary, constitutional objective of delivering high-quality services, with profitability subordinate to that broader aim” (Andy Burnham talks about ‘public control’ of the utilities but it’s a minefield. We can lead him through it, 25 September). So still companies, but with a public interest rather than a profit motive. This is still the wrong approach.

    Utilities should not be run as businesses but as essential public services. They do not function in isolation, and business models are unsuited to their functioning in the public interest. They have social and environmental as well as economic responsibilities that have to be met. For 20 years, prior to the advent of the Scottish parliament, local government functioned well in Scotland within a framework of regions and districts. The regions had powers and responsibilities for the wide range of functions that had to be coordinated and operated strategically at the regional level. They included water and sewerage.

    The present government appears to be edging sideways, through metro mayors and joint working, towards governance for city regions. This should be formalised and given a full portfolio of responsibilities, powers and resources for strategic planning, economic development, education, health, transportation, infrastructure and the environment. Infrastructure should include water and sewerage.

    As an example, urban rainwater needs to be collected and recycled for cooling, which was normal practice for thousands of years in southern Europe. Such practice should be moving north to include water reserves for wildfire control. How could such provisions, urban cooling and wildfire control ever be met through the profit motive?

    If the present water companies in England have liabilities that exceed the value of their assets, and cannot meet their legal responsibilities, then it is difficult to see why they should be rescued and maintained through public expenditure.
    Roger Read
    Former secretary general, Metrex

    Will Hutton and Andy Haldane put forward a poor argument for maintaining private ownership of utilities. Instead of comparing the present situation with how things were when the water utilities were publicly owned – surely the fairest comparison – they cite spurious examples of the alleged failings of other nationalised industries.

    We are alone in the world (apart from Chile) in having a wholly privatised water industry; is everyone else out of step?
    Sally Thompson
    Cardiff

    Will Hutton and Andy Haldane give some interesting thoughts on the public control of utilities. These could also apply across the complete essential services sector, from water companies to dental practices. Few who experienced the performance of the old postwar nationalised industries would wish a return to this failed model. However, why not just keep it simple and legislate to force all essential-services operators to list as companies on the London Stock Exchange?

    For each sector, further legislation could set maximums for yields and permitted borrowing: two key indicators of company activity. The public would then be more inclined to invest in the companies, just as they do at present with National Grid.
    Ian Graham
    Port Carlisle, Cumbria

    Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleAvoiding the “zombie” risk with Property Accounting Software
    Next Article UK homes are more affordable than they’ve been in 11 years. Here’s where buyers still struggle

    Related Posts

    Utilities

    Are Utilities Stocks Lagging Entergy (ETR) This Year?

    November 12, 2026
    Utilities

    Acquisition adds weight to RSK Group’s utilities and infrastructure offering

    November 12, 2026
    Utilities

    Half-year earnings surge at United Utilities

    November 12, 2026
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    How is the UK Commercial Property Market Performing?

    December 31, 2000

    How much are they in different states across the US?

    December 31, 2000

    A Guide To Becoming A Property Developer

    December 31, 2000
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • WhatsApp
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Latest Reviews
    Investing

    UBS raises stock price target for Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway By Investing.com

    October 21, 2024
    Property

    The common problem that could be wiping £50k from your property value | UK | News

    March 13, 2025
    Stock Market

    Stock Market Update: Trades Executed Today To Be Settled On Wednesday Instead Of Tomorrow | Markets News

    September 7, 2025
    What's Hot

    Bitcoin’s biggest quantum risk may not be wallet keys. An early investor fears something bigger

    May 29, 2026

    Save 60% on this desktop Bitcoin miner that’s smaller than a deck of cards

    June 23, 2026

    Open Interest in Bitcoin Skyrockets from $2 Billion at the Dawn of a Fed Reversal

    August 23, 2024
    Most Popular

    AI Models Prefer Bitcoin Over Fiat and Stablecoins, Study Finds

    March 3, 2026

    ‘The Fintech Reckoning’: London’s IPO Stock Exchange Slump

    October 11, 2024

    8 Bullish Technical Setups Flashing Strong Buy Signals Today

    August 19, 2025
    Editor's Picks

    Cathie Wood buys falling tech stocks: Amazon, Meta, Tesla

    August 9, 2024

    Capital One offers $265B benefit plan to appease regulators for its planned purchase of Discover

    July 18, 2024

    Family Fight at the Fed Gives Way to Capitulation Selling and a Strong Rebound

    July 30, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
    • Get In Touch
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    © 2026 Invest Insider News

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.