Close Menu
Invest Insider News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Tuesday, November 17
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
    Invest Insider News
    • Home
    • Bitcoin
    • Commodities
    • Finance
    • Investing
    • Property
    • Stock Market
    • Utilities
    Invest Insider News
    Home»Property»A lone protester highlights the pain from China’s property bust
    Property

    A lone protester highlights the pain from China’s property bust

    November 16, 20265 Mins Read


    The most famous protester in modern Chinese history is “tank man”, the anonymous pedestrian who stared down a line of tanks next to Tiananmen Square in 1989. Last week a new protester captivated audiences beyond China: excavator man. On November 9th he drove a yellow construction digger up to a large government building in western China and started to rip at its façade—all caught on bystanders’ mobile phones. Part of the fascination with the story lay in the desperation of his act. The building, like the government itself, was at no risk of being toppled; the only certain outcome was that the man would be locked up.

    Screengrab
    Screengrab

    Four days after videos of his protest spread across social media, Chaguan visited the site in Fengdong New City, just west of the historic capital of Xi’an. Dozens of police stood in front of the building—a service centre for the public. Hoardings already covered the walls struck by the man, who was identified by officials only as Mr Hu, aged 47. Workers drilled and hammered as they repaired the damage. Inside, people paid taxes and registered companies as usual. With police there, no one tarried to take photos.

    But in the streets nearby, seemingly everyone knew about the protest. “It was a spectacle. We were all gawping,” said a shopkeeper. Officials have given no motive. Two versions have circulated online: one is that Mr Hu was owed money for construction work; the other that he was aggrieved over compensation for his demolished farm. A longtime resident on his way out of the service centre blamed the sprawling development across the street, where a village had been razed to make way for a thicket of office buildings and housing blocks. One thing, he said, was clear. “The government doesn’t have the money to pay what it owes. Even a clever cook can’t make a meal without rice.”

    Whichever version is true, the saga in Fengdong is an extreme case of a grim reality for many: a property bust has drained local coffers, and ordinary people are last in line to be paid. Some are being pushed to the brink—and, as in the case of excavator man, over it. Chinese provinces and cities used to rely on land sales to generate nearly half their revenue. When the property sector went cold, land sales came to a halt, leaving local governments struggling to pay bills. Richer coastal cities are building new high-tech industries and broader tax bases. Places inland like Fengdong have had no such luck. They were in the midst of massive building sprees as the music stopped, and have little share of China’s new tech-driven economy.

    The area around Mr Hu’s protest bears the scars of the property crash. Across the street from the building he attacked is the concrete core of a skyscraper that was supposed to reach 100 storeys, making it the tallest tower in north-western China, but it remains incomplete. Work stopped two years ago. Around it are other half-finished buildings; completed ones have padlocked doors, shattered glass and to-let signs. The troubles have reached the local government’s balance sheet. In May the state-owned group that oversees development of the Xixian New Area, which includes Fengdong, disclosed that it had nearly 3.7bn yuan ($550m) in overdue debt.

    Signs of progress are few and faint. A nearby industrial park has attracted a genomics firm and a software developer. One forlorn building was repurposed a few months ago as a hub for “one-person companies”: small startups powered, supposedly, by artificial intelligence. Walking through its empty corridors, a visitor might call them “zero-person companies”. Even if some do eventually help the economy to grow, they will produce nothing like the windfall a decade ago from selling vast tracts of land. The government “can’t sell more land”, said the resident exaggerating only slightly.

    Many places around China are in similar difficulty. In the first half of 2026 more than two-thirds of local-government financing vehicles—state-owned firms that turned land into property developments—did not earn enough to cover their interest payments, according to S&P, a credit-rating agency. Payments to suppliers are chronically late. Money owed to construction workers or to villagers as compensation easily slides to the bottom of the pile of bills. “There is nothing you can do. Suing them is pointless,” said a former road-construction contractor. In Fengdong, villagers showed up at the service centre every day for a month to demand payment, all to no avail, said the shopkeeper. “Officials delay and delay until they are transferred elsewhere,” he added.

    One of Xi Jinping’s solutions has been to create a system of lifetime responsibility for debt. A party secretary or mayor who makes a mess like the one in Fengdong will, in theory, be on the hook many years later. That makes sense, but it has added to the chill: who wants to take risks that could haunt them forever? Pretty much the only construction in Fengdong was the renovation of the building damaged by Mr Hu.

    Grated expectations

    Do his actions signify that more people are beginning to vent their discontent in public? The contractor said a lesson from China’s long history is that it takes just one person to light a fire. On social media, the vast majority of comments were sympathetic. “Ordinary people have suffered too much,” read a typical one.

    Yet there is scant evidence that Mr Hu’s lone act promises a popular movement. For potential copycats, the consequences are too frightening and the benefits too negligible. As a delivery driver in Fengdong put it, the important thing now is to get used to lower expectations. He can still put food on the table, so the situation is tolerable. That is hardly a ringing endorsement of his life. But as far as officials are concerned, what matters is that it is not a stinging denunciation. They can live with one excavator man.

    Subscribers to The Economist can sign up to our Opinion newsletter, which brings together the best of our leaders, columns, guest essays and reader correspondence.



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleKospi slumps nearly 2%; Asian markets fall as AI sell-off deepens ahead of Nvidia results, Anthropic IPO
    Next Article As Bitcoin Plummets, Trump Media Warns It May Have To Sell Some To Repay Noteholders. Here’s Why Nov. 30 Is The Key Date For Its $1 Billion In Notes

    Related Posts

    Property

    Dorset Council leader to discuss future of housing and development

    November 17, 2026
    Property

    China’s Home Prices Hit New Low: October Decline at 2.4% Signals Continued Real Estate Struggles, ETRealty

    November 15, 2026
    Property

    Rightmove and Zoopla’s statement as buyers feel catfished over AI property pics

    November 13, 2026
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    How is the UK Commercial Property Market Performing?

    December 31, 2000

    How much are they in different states across the US?

    December 31, 2000

    A Guide To Becoming A Property Developer

    December 31, 2000
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • TikTok
    • WhatsApp
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Latest Reviews
    Property

    Some bills will double, others will go down. Find out what you’ll pay – The Irish Times

    October 27, 2025
    Investing

    Inflation Relief Arrives as Core CPI Cools and Markets Eye the Fed

    June 10, 2026
    Stock Market

    Stock Market Live May 7, 2026: S&P 500 (SPY) Could See Higher Highs

    May 7, 2026
    What's Hot

    Location, Location, Location’s Phil Spencer shares key property upgrades which will make your home stand out to buyers (and they won’t break the bank!)

    September 1, 2025

    Saviez-vous? Max Keizer a prédit 1 million de dollars Bitcoin en 2010

    June 28, 2025

    Stock Market Today, June 3: Rivian Automotive Jumps on Strong R2 SUV Order Interest

    June 3, 2026
    Most Popular

    Real estate agent’s ‘wild’ discovery about Australia after moving to America: ‘Can someone please help?’

    December 1, 2025

    The Commodities Feed: Tug of war between oil supply risks and market surplus | articles

    November 16, 2025

    Voici deux formations haussiers qui pourraient prendre le bitcoin au-dessus de 295 000 $

    May 28, 2025
    Editor's Picks

    FTSE 100 today: Stocks slide as Trump’s Iran deal clock ticks down By Investing.com

    June 9, 2026

    Leading Transformation Amid Uncertainty And Innovation

    December 2, 2025

    Bitcoin Price Prediction as Companies Dump Their Bitcoin

    April 6, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
    • Get In Touch
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    © 2026 Invest Insider News

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.