The true scale of the financial crisis facing Wales’ schools is laid bare in troubling data which shows the huge sums in debt schools carry over every financial year.
Latest Welsh Government figures show the number of schools in the red at the end of the financial year has grown significantly in the last five years – and that the amount those schools owe is also growing.
The deficit one small primary school carried over at the end of the last financial year was so large it is equivalent to £10,280 for every one of the 28 pupils on the school roll.
At bigger schools, the deficits at the end of the financial year can reach more than £2m. Four schools carried over deficits of more than £2m and 20 had deficits of more than £1m.
One headteacher said they are “genuinely struggling to afford everyday essentials, including paper, stationery and even toilet rolls.” Others describe leaking rooves, classes at capacity and cuts to extra help for the least and most able.
With nearly half of all secondary schools and one in three primaries now in deficit, the Association of School and College Leaders Cymru is among those calling for reform to the way schools are funded warning the financial abyss is not sustainable.
Of the 1,441 schools in Wales, 492 were listed as in deficit in the latest Welsh Government official data, published last month for 2025-26. That’s 106 more schools than registered deficits in 2024-25.
With around 90% of school spend going on staff salaries governors say there is little room for manoeuvre, especially after wage rises, some of which have not been fully funded.
As schools grapple to balance the books, heads say they are having to make “unpalatable” cuts including job losses, larger class sizes and reduced subject choices, leaving some headteachers in tears. Bills have been rising and real term income falling as well as added pressure having to meet new legal requirements for additional learning needs, they said.
Savings also include exam subject choices narrowed and extra help for pupils slashed. One primary headteacher with a £200,000 deficit described the funding system as broken after losing two teachers, a learning assistant and his assistant head in multiple rounds of redundancies.
All classes at one headteacher’s school are are now at the legal maximum of 30 children and he said his, like other schools, are unable to provide the staff/child ratio recommended of one to eight for the youngest in the Foundation Phase where it is now one to 15.
“The roof leaks and the carpets are coming up, everybody is suffering,” the headteacher, who did not want to be named for fear of reprisals.
He said the “huge rise” in children with additional needs and changes in the law around what schools must provide for them is the cause of most school deficits.
Ensure our latest news and sport headlines always appear at the top of your Google Search by making us a Preferred Source. Click here to activate or add us as Preferred Source in your Google search settings
Kerry Jones, chair of governors at Ysgol Eiras in Conwy said his school has borrowed two lots of £300,000 from its local education authority, a debt that must now be re-paid adding to pressure as it runs a continued deficit . The loan came from reserves of other schools in the county and was essentially “robbing Peter to pay Paul”, Mr Jones pointed out.
Governors, school leaders and staff unions blame the financial crisis on years of cuts in real terms funding amid spiralling costs and insist it is not down to bad budgeting or overspends.
Mr Jones summed up the feelings of many who run schools saying: “We have got to the limit. If we lose more staff we won’t be able to deliver the curriculum and we are on the threshold of that. We are not overspending.”
Another governor, who did not want to be named said: “The pressure on headteachers and chairs of governors is huge as they are forced to make unpalatable cuts.
“Some school leaders are saying that they cannot provide a safe environment and adequate level of teaching and learning for the money they are given.”
School deficits fell during the pandemic. At the lowest, only 44 schools had deficits in 2021-22. However the financial problems have been growing ever since and for the last three year, the number of schools in deficit has grown past the pre-pandemic peak of 313 schools in the red in 2019-20.
Deficits are now at levels which even threaten some local authorities’ overall financial outlook.
The Vale of Glamorgan has been cited as a concern by Audit Wales with its total school deficits now nearing the local authority’s overall total reserves.
As a largely affluent area, schools in the Vale receive less funding than many areas under the Welsh Government’s Pupil Development Grant. This means some schools rack up higher deficits.
Cllr Rhiannon Birch, VoG’s cabinet member for education, said nearly 40% of council spending goes directly to schools and the authority is working with schools to manage budgets.
“Financial pressures on education are significant and are recognised by the council as a corporate risk,” she admitted.
“Schools are facing rising costs and increased demand for additional learning needs (ALN) provision and support for pupils’ social, emotional and mental health, while funding (via government) has not kept pace with these pressures.”
A covering note for the Audit Wales report, which went to the VoG’s governence and audit committee on October 12, details how the council’s cumulative school deficits increased from £4.1m in 2024-25 to £10.8m at March 2026 and are forecast to reach £22m by 2029.
While this represents an improvement on previous eye watering forecasts of £43.9m deficits, before action began, Audit Wales concluded that the position continues to exceed the council’s reserves and poses a significant risk to the council’s financial sustainability.
These problems are mirrored elsewhere across Wales. Cuts listed by schools include stopping extra exam help for the most deprived children, a key tool in narrowing the ever widening attainment gap between Wales’ richest and poorest pupils.
It’s not just deprived pupils missing out. Extra help for especially academically able pupils has also been axed in some areas.
Top five school largest deficits in 2025/6
- Ysgol Gyfun Cwm Rhymni, Caerphilly (-£2,717,000)
- King Henry VIII 3-19 School, Monmouthshire (-£2,241,000)
- Ysgol Gyfun Emlyn, Carmarthenshire (-£2,180,670)
- Ysgol Bro Dinefwr, Carmarthenshire(-£2,114,564)
- Ysgol Calon Cymru, Powys (-£1,984,434)
The biggest deficit increases were at Pencoedtre High School in Barry, Vale of Glamorgan. Its debt carried over grew from £301k to £1,336k and King Henry VIII school in Abergavenny, Monmouthshire, where debt carried over grew from £1,368k to £2,241k.
Top 5 Largest Primary Deficits
- Alderman Davies CIW Primary, Neath Port Talbot, -£1,822,000 (232 pupils)
- Gladstone Primary, Barry, Vale of Glamorgan-£1,277,230 (415 pupils)
- Romilly Community Primary, Barry, Vale of Glamorgan-£1,152,220 (647 pupils)
- Rhws Primary School, Rhoose, Vale of Glamorgan: -£934,020 (372 pupils)
- Colcot Primary, Barry Vale of Glamorgan -£745,630 (267 pupils)
Top 5 Largest Special School Deficit
- Heol Goffa, Llanelli, Carmarthenshire -£632,320 (132 pupils)
- Ysgol Calon Lan, Swansea -£508,880 (240 pupils)
- The River Centre 3-16 Learning Community, Ebbw Vale, Blaenau Gwent -£463,740 (66 pupils)
- Ysgol Cynefin, Cardiff -£382,550 (42 pupils)
- St Christophers School, Wrexham £323,000 (341 pupils)
ALN funding fury
There is fury among school leaders and unions that millions of pounds which they say should have come to Welsh schools in ALN funding under the Barnett Formula has gone to other Welsh Government budgets instead.
After the Welsh Government’s mini budget was agreed on November 3 Dr Graham Gault, national secretary of school leaders’ union NAHT, said his members are now balloting for possible industrial action on this matter.
While £60m in additional ALN funding came to schools as part of other money in that budget, they were denied the full £322m they should be entitled to under the Barnett formula Wales as a result of extra special educational needs funding in England, Dr Gault said.
The NEU has now written to the Auditor General to “investigate what has happened to this missing money”.
Dr Gault had withering words for the new Plaid Cymru administration.
“Since this data was gathered, the financial pressures facing many Welsh schools have only intensified.
“Some school leaders are facing soul-destroying choices between cutting teachers and teaching assistants, or broader learning provision and resources, but even these awful decisions may not be enough to prevent them falling into deficit.
Many school buildings are in a very poor condition but leaders simply don’t have the money to do anything about it.
“Schools are being expected to do more with less amid pressures including the increasing numbers of pupils with additional learning needs (ALN), rising costs, and the extra demands generated by a failure over many years to invest properly in health and social care amid growing demand.
“The new Welsh Government had an opportunity to really prioritise education funding, and right the wrong whereby schools have been denied a fair share of additional ‘consequential’ money received from the UK government, including for support with ALN.
“It has largely spurned that opportunity. Despite some extra money for ALN, this remains much less than the consequential funding schools should be entitled to extra to and is not enough to meet the demands schools are facing.
“That is one of the reasons why our members felt they had no alternative but to ballot for industrial action.
“With the best will in the world on the part of school leaders and their staff, there are limits on their ability to absorb and mitigate the impact of funding shortfalls – ultimately, it is children’s learning which suffers.”
In response the Welsh Government said that devolution means Welsh Ministers decide how funding is spent in Wales based on the nation’s needs and priorities and there had been “difficult decisions”.
A spokesperson said: The Welsh Government said: “As a new administration, we were informed that our public services were facing severe in-year pressures in 2026-27, with the NHS alone facing a net deficit of over £300 million. This has led to difficult decisions having to be made across our portfolio.’
“Devolution means Welsh Ministers decide how funding is spent in Wales based on the nation’s needs and priorities. We will publish our draft budget for 2027-2028 and beyond later this month.
“Decisions on the level of funding available to schools and to other services are made by individual local authorities as part of their overall budget and council tax setting.”
Responding directly to NAHT’s comments around ALN funding the spokeperson added: “NAHT Cymru has made clear that pay and workload are a priority for members.
“We are pleased that, despite the extremely challenging financial climate, we have been able to agree a 3.5% pay increase this year for teachers and school leaders, and a 5% uplift to the unqualified teachers’ pay scale. This upholds the no-detriment principle with England, which has been a priority for all our union partners. Funding has been provided to local authorities to cover the cost of these awards, so that school budgets are protected.
“We are also pleased that the Senedd agreed the supplementary budget which will deliver an additional £60m in 2026-27 to support ALN learners in schools and colleges, the vast majority of which has gone direct to schools.
“This funding will help reduce workload and support teacher well-being, and we are ready to resume discussions on related matters with NAHT Cymru and employers at any time.
“As a new administration, we were informed that our public services were facing severe in-year pressures in 2026-27, with the NHS alone facing a net deficit of over £300m. In response, we are delivering historically-high levels of savings and efficiencies to ensure the sustainability of services this year and beyond.”
“Devolution means Welsh Ministers decide how funding is spent in Wales based on the nation’s needs and priorities. We will publish our draft budget for 2027-2028 and beyond later this month. Consequential funding has been used, in line with our responsibilities as a devolved government, to mitigate the significant pressures on all of our public services.”
What’s to blame for the financial black hole?
School bills are rising and real terms income falling during the cost of living and fuel crisis. The extra cash schools got during and post-pandemic has now gone.
Schools say they don’t get enough cash from councils, who say they don’t get enough from the Welsh Government, which in turn passes the buck to the UK government.
The Association of School and College Leaders Cymru is among those calling for the “blame game” to stop and a sustainable funding model devised.
At the moment schools are funded per pupil calculated differently in all 22 local education authorities. Some areas are badly affected by falling numbers of pupils.
Per pupil spend for post-16 college education is uniform around Wales, which some school governors want replicated for schools.
Martin Price, chair of the Vale of Glamorgan School Governors Association, believes “Wales as a whole is over managed”. He wants more money for education to go directly to schools.
“All schools in Wales are spending their reserves,” he said, “The Vale is ahead of the curve because it has been underfunded for years coping with the out of date local authority (per pupil) funding formula.
“Other smaller local authorities are also struggling – Conwy , Merthyr, Monmouthshire.
“More than half of Vale schools were in substantial deficit by March 2026. Most Welsh schools will have spent their reserves by March 2027.
“A fundamental problem is the allocation of funding to schools. Each local authority receives an allocation on an outdated formula, and then there are 22 different formulas for how that is distributed to schools within each local authority.
“By contrast in England there is a standard national formula starting with a fixed allocation per pupil, with additions for deprivation, ALN, etc.
“In Wales, post 16 education – A levels and vocational courses – is funded in this way with a fixed nationally agreed amount per student, irrespective of where they live.
“Fundamentally, Welsh Education is overmanaged by 22 Local Authorities. with a complicated unfair allocation of funding.”
Sally Llewellyn, head of school improvement and learning at Powys County Council, where 31 of 95 schools are in deficit, including £1.9+m each at Brecon High and Ysgol Calon Lan, desrcribed the position as “fragile”.
“Financial pressures on schools remain a significant concern for Powys, particularly in response to continued inflationary pressure and nationally agreed pay awards for teachers and other school staff,” she said.
“Individual schools in deficit will need to reduce expenditure as part of their recovery plans, while the council continues its longer-term work to ensure that education provision across Powys is financially sustainable.”
As they wrestle with budgets schools are finding is ever harder to recruit and retain headteachers and volunteer school governors.
Jane Morris, Director of Governors Cymru Services, which offers advice and support to governing bodies said: “There is only so much governors and their senior leaders can do when budgets are increasingly stretched and difficult decisions about priorities and staffing have to be made.
“A sustainable and long-term approach to school funding is needed that recognises the considerable pressures schools encounter daily and which ensures every child has access to the best education, support and opportunities.”
As her warning came one governor described seeing a headteacher reduced to tears in a budget meeting. This was unlikely to be an isolated case. They said the impossible task of running a school with often inadequate funds is having an effect on school leaders’ wellbeing.
Perhaps the last word should go to Kerry Jones, independent chair of governors at Ysgol Eiras. After more than three decades there and at other schools he is one of Wales’ longest serving and most experienced governors.
Mr Jones, a retired BT worker who worked in business all his life, doesn’t recall pressure as it is now. He says underfunding schools matters for everyone in Wales.
“The better education we give our children the better the future for Wales. Education affects health and the economy. Better education means better jobs, more money and better health.”
